Structured Settlements for Plaintiff Attorneys
***NEWSLETTER***
Why the Planning Needs to Start Before the Case Settles
For plaintiff attorneys, much of the case is about getting to the number.
Establish liability. Prove damages. Develop the medical record. Negotiate. Mediate. Try the case if necessary. Resolve the liens. Calculate fees and costs. Determine what ultimately remains for the client.
But once the net recovery is known, another question emerges:
What should happen to the money?
That question sits outside the traditional litigation lane, but it can materially affect the value the client ultimately receives from the settlement.
A structured settlement can convert a portion of today’s recovery into payments designed around future needs. For some clients, that may mean monthly income. For a minor, it may mean money for college, a home, or adulthood. For a catastrophically injured plaintiff, it may mean income designed to continue for life. For another client, the appropriate answer may simply be taking the settlement in cash.
The important point is that the client should have the opportunity to make that decision before the settlement mechanics make the decision for them.
That is the focus of Lien Project Network’s conversation between John Rice and structured settlement consultant Manny Valdez, Jr.: Structured Settlements for Plaintiff Attorneys: What to Know Before the Case Settles.
A $25,000 Decision That Paid for College
John begins the conversation with a story from his own plaintiff practice.
Early in his career, John resolved a significant case and earned approximately $75,000 in attorney fees. The plaintiff was using a structured settlement for part of the recovery. Manny Valdez, Sr. encouraged John to consider doing something similar with a portion of his fee.
John ultimately deferred $25,000.
The payments were scheduled years into the future, around the time his young son would reach college age. John largely forgot about them.
Then his son was accepted to Berkeley.
Just as John was preparing for the financial reality of college tuition, the first scheduled payment arrived. Additional payments followed over the next several years and ultimately covered much of his son’s education.
The story captures something that can get lost when structured settlements are discussed only in technical terms.
A structure is not simply about an annuity.
It is about matching money to a future need.
What Is a Structured Settlement?
At its simplest, a structured settlement allows some portion of a settlement to be paid through future periodic payments rather than entirely as an immediate lump sum.
For qualifying damages received because of personal physical injury or physical sickness, Internal Revenue Code section 104(a)(2) generally excludes the compensatory recovery from gross income whether the damages are received as a lump sum or through periodic payments. Punitive damages and other types of recovery may receive different tax treatment, which is why the nature of the underlying settlement remains important.
The structured settlement framework can use a qualified assignment under Internal Revenue Code section 130, with the future payment obligation funded through qualifying assets such as an annuity contract. The payment schedule is established as part of the settlement rather than after the plaintiff has already received the money.
For the client, the structure does not have to be all or nothing.
A plaintiff may receive substantial cash at settlement and place another portion into future payments. In practice, that flexibility is often the point.
The question is not simply, “cash or structure?”
It is:
How much cash does this client need now, and what portion of the recovery may serve them better in the future?
The Power of Deferral
Time can dramatically change what a settlement dollar can accomplish.
If payments begin almost immediately, the money has comparatively little time to grow before it is returned to the client. If payments are deferred for many years, the funding has more time to work before distributions begin.
That can make structured planning particularly relevant when the need being funded is itself years away.
College is an obvious example. So is retirement. A minor may not need access to a significant portion of the settlement for ten, fifteen, or twenty years. A young adult may want future income beginning later in life. A catastrophically injured client may need to coordinate settlement funds with projected future care.
The payment schedule can be designed around those needs.
That is fundamentally different from simply handing the client a large check and hoping the money lasts.
Minors Show the Planning Opportunity Clearly
Minor settlements provide one of the clearest examples.
Without alternative planning, settlement proceeds may be placed into a blocked account until the child reaches the age established by applicable law or court order. That provides security, but it does not necessarily address how the money should serve the child once access becomes available.
Structured planning can create a different roadmap.
Rather than giving the young adult access to the entire recovery at one time, payments can potentially be coordinated with life stages. Funds may become available around college, early adulthood, a first home, or later financial needs.
The conversation between John and Manny also explores newer planning approaches that may blend traditional fixed payment options with indexed or market based components in appropriate circumstances. Those approaches involve different levels of risk, guarantees, cost, and court scrutiny.
That deeper comparison belongs in the full module.
The larger point for plaintiff counsel is simpler: a minor’s compromise should involve more than determining where the settlement will sit until adulthood.
It should also prompt a conversation about what the money is intended to accomplish.
Does Every Case Need a Structure?
No.
But almost every meaningful recovery may justify asking the question.
Some clients need their recovery immediately. They may have debt, housing needs, transportation expenses, unpaid medical costs, or basic living expenses that make deferral impractical.
Other clients may receive an amount too small to justify complicated planning.
But that does not necessarily mean plaintiff counsel should make the decision for them.
John’s framing in the conversation is important. The plaintiff lawyer’s job is to ring the bell and maximize the tort recovery. Financial planning is a different lane.
Counsel does not need to recommend a particular annuity, investment, or payment design. But where the recovery is meaningful, counsel can make sure the client knows that alternatives to receiving one lump sum exist and can provide access to someone qualified to explain them.
The decision then belongs to the client.
Timing Is Everything
This may be the most important practice point in the entire conversation.
Do not wait until the settlement has already been completed to introduce structured settlement planning.
Manny’s preference is to become involved once settlement becomes a realistic possibility, whether that means a demand has been exchanged, mediation has been scheduled, or meaningful negotiations have begun.
That timing gives the client room to think.
A settlement involving hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars can represent more money than the client has ever managed. Asking the client to make long term financial decisions during the final forty eight hours of settlement documentation is not ideal.
Early involvement allows the client to consider practical questions. What does the household budget look like? What future expenses are expected? Is retirement adequately funded? Are there anticipated medical costs? Does the client need immediate liquidity? Are children involved? Are public benefits involved?
Those conversations take time.
They also create a better informed client.
Do Not Forget the Settlement Agreement
Early planning also matters because structured settlements require coordination with the settling defendant and carrier.
One practical recommendation from the conversation is particularly useful for plaintiff attorneys: when settlement is reached at mediation, consider preserving the plaintiff’s ability to implement a structure as part of the settlement terms.
That prevents an avoidable problem later.
Structured settlement implementation may require the defense to participate in funding and settlement documentation. Qualified assignment language, periodic payment terms, releases, and payment instructions may all need to be coordinated before settlement proceeds are distributed.
The planner can assist with those mechanics, but only if the planner is brought into the case before it is too late.
Once the Money Moves, the Options Change
Timing also intersects with constructive receipt.
A qualifying structured settlement is established as part of the settlement arrangement. The plaintiff cannot simply receive the cash, place it into the attorney trust account for unrestricted distribution, and then later decide to recreate the same tax treatment by purchasing an annuity personally.
Anyone can purchase an annuity.
That is different from establishing a qualifying structured settlement within the settlement transaction.
The tax rules governing structured settlements contemplate periodic payments established through the settlement or qualified assignment process, which is another reason the decision needs to be made before settlement proceeds are distributed.
For plaintiff counsel, that translates into a simple practice rule:
If the client may want a structure, raise the issue before the money moves.
Life Expectancy Can Change the Economics
Catastrophic injury cases add another dimension: life expectancy.
Structured settlement providers may review medical information and assign what is commonly called a rated age. The concept reflects the provider’s assessment that the claimant’s medical circumstances may result in a different actuarial life expectancy than that of an otherwise healthy person of the same chronological age.
That can materially affect the pricing of lifetime payment options.
For plaintiff lawyers, the subject is particularly interesting because life expectancy may already be central to the damages case. Life care planners, economists, physicians, and defense experts may have spent years debating how long the plaintiff is expected to live and what future care will cost.
Once the case settles, that same medical history can become part of a different analysis: how settlement proceeds can be designed to support the client for as long as the client actually lives.
A lifetime payment stream can shift longevity risk away from the plaintiff and toward the provider responsible for making those payments.
The full conversation goes deeper into rated ages, temporary life payments, lifetime payments, guarantees, and how medical underwriting can affect the economics of a structure.
Structured Settlements and Public Benefits Planning
Financial planning cannot be separated from public benefits planning when the client depends on programs such as Medi Cal or SSI.
A plaintiff may resolve the liens, net a substantial recovery, and still face a separate question about whether receiving that money directly will affect continued eligibility for means tested benefits.
That is where the different planning lanes begin to overlap.
A special needs trust may be appropriate for certain clients. Structured settlement payments may also be coordinated with a properly established trust so that the trust, rather than the individual beneficiary, receives the designated payments.
That does not mean every Medi Cal beneficiary needs a special needs trust or every trust should be funded with a structure.
It means the financial planner, public benefits attorney, trust attorney, and plaintiff lawyer may need to coordinate before settlement.
This reflects the broader framework John has described throughout the Lien Project Network series: lien resolution gets the case to the net, financial planning determines how the net may work for the client, and public benefits planning addresses whether receiving or controlling those funds may affect important benefits.
Three different lanes.
One settlement.
Plaintiff Attorneys Have Their Own Planning Opportunity
The structured settlement conversation does not necessarily end with the client.
Contingent fee attorneys may also have the ability, when properly arranged before the fee becomes currently receivable, to defer receipt of some attorney fees. In Childs v. Commissioner, the Tax Court upheld an arrangement in which contingent fee attorneys received their fees over time rather than recognizing the entire fee when the underlying cases settled. The Eleventh Circuit later affirmed the decision.
The timing and structure of the arrangement matter. Attorney fee deferral should therefore be coordinated with appropriate tax and financial professionals rather than treated as an afterthought once the fee has already been received or become unconditionally available.
For plaintiff attorneys, however, the planning possibilities are significant.
A fee structure may potentially be designed around retirement, education expenses, future firm overhead, or other anticipated needs. An attorney does not necessarily need to wait for one extraordinary verdict or settlement. Smaller amounts from multiple matters may also form part of a broader long term strategy.
John’s own college funding story demonstrates the concept better than any tax lecture could.
Sometimes the money you choose not to take today becomes the money you are happiest to receive years later.
The Plaintiff Lawyer Does Not Need to Become the Financial Planner
There is an important professional boundary running through the entire discussion.
Plaintiff attorneys should generally not be selecting investment products, predicting market performance, or designing comprehensive financial plans for clients.
That is not the litigation lawyer’s lane.
The attorney’s role is to recognize when the issue exists and make the appropriate introduction.
A useful settlement process may therefore include the following:
- Determine the likely net recovery before the case is fully documented for settlement.
- Ask whether the client has immediate and future financial needs that warrant a planning discussion.
- Identify whether the client receives public benefits or has special needs planning considerations.
- Introduce a qualified settlement planner early enough for the client to understand the available options.
- Preserve structured settlement cooperation in mediation and settlement terms when appropriate.
- Coordinate any structure, trust, or public benefits planning before settlement proceeds are distributed.
- Document the client’s decision, including when the client elects not to pursue structured planning.
The plaintiff lawyer remains focused on the tort case.
The client simply receives access to another professional whose job begins where the litigation lawyer’s ends.
Watch the Full Conversation
This blog provides the framework.
The full Lien Project Network conversation between John Rice and Manny Valdez, Jr. goes significantly deeper into the mechanics and strategy behind structured settlements.
They discuss traditional fixed structures, indexed and market based options, planning for minors, the power of long term deferral, compensation and fees, rated ages, lifetime payments, mediation and settlement language, constructive receipt, public benefits coordination, special needs trusts, and structured attorney fees.
They also address the practical questions plaintiff attorneys frequently ask: when should the planner become involved, what information does the planner need, how does the defense participate, and what happens if everyone waits until after the case settles?
The recurring answer is simple.
Call earlier.
The more time the client has to understand the choices, the easier it becomes to build settlement planning around the client’s actual life rather than asking the client to make a major financial decision while everyone is trying to close the file.
Visit www.lienprojectnetwork.com to access the full module and additional plaintiff attorney resources on settlement planning, lien resolution, public benefits, and protecting client net recovery.
The Bottom Line
Plaintiff attorneys spend years building value into a case.
Structured settlement planning asks what happens to that value after the litigation ends.
For some clients, cash will be the right answer. For others, a combination of immediate funds and future payments may better match the reason the case was pursued in the first place: replacing lost income, funding future care, protecting a minor, providing financial stability, or helping a family move forward after a life changing injury.
The plaintiff lawyer does not need to make that financial decision.
But counsel can make sure the client has the opportunity to make it intelligently.
Resolve the liens. Get to the net. Then make sure the client understands what the net can do.
MANTRAS FOR PERSONAL INJURY LIEN RESOLUTION IN 2026
DO MORE. BE BETTER.
Get trained. Stay compliant. Protect your client.
Need Assistance? Work With The Lien Project, PC
If you need expert legal assistance in navigating lien resolution, reimbursement claims, or settlement planning, our team at The Lien Project, PC is ready to help. As an LPN member, you earn credits that can be applied toward lien reduction and resolution services provided by The Lien Project, PC, allowing you to offset up to $900 per year. Your investment in continuing education through Lien Project Network not only enhances your lien resolution skills but also reduces the cost of engaging legal experts when needed.
Schedule a Consult today to see how we can help maximize your client’s recovery.
